Are you getting ready to replace your roof and considering the differences between standing seam metal roofing and asphalt shingles? If so, you probably have lots of questions.
Here are a few of the most common questions asked by the hundreds of homeowners we’ve served in Illinois and Indiana. If you’re still curious about metal roofs after scrolling, be sure to reach out for a free onsite consultation and detailed quote!
Choosing between metal roofs vs shingles comes down to neighborhood aesthetics, short-term budget, and how long you’ll be staying in your home.
As a rule, metal roofs are the superior choice for long-term value, durability, and energy efficiency. However, asphalt shingles are still a popular choice for their lower upfront cost and traditional aesthetic.
Here’s the breakdown:
Standing seam metal roofs cost 2–3x more than asphalt shingles at installation. However, they’re also the cheaper option over the long-term, paying for themselves over 15–25 years in saved maintenance bills, lower utility costs, and zero replacement concerns for 40–70+ years.
Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, are prized for upfront lower costs (½ to ⅓ the cost of metal) and a traditional look. The catch is they only last 15–30 years, don’t stand up to harsh weather as well, are generally higher maintenance, and absorb heat in the summer—leading to higher cooling costs.
While both are viable options depending on your goals, it’s best to explore both thoroughly with a trusted roofer in your area before deciding. A new roof is a big deal!

Standing seam metal roofs are roofing systems made of long metal panels running vertically down your roof’s ridge to the eaves (the final bit overhanging your siding).
Standing seam panels lock into one another with seams raised above the panel surface. This clever design keeps all seams above the water running off the roof—even in heavy thunderstorms. Additionally, standing seam panels hide all fasteners and screws underneath the panels. This eliminates the vulnerable points created when screws are driven through your roof.
Standing seam metal roofs can easily last 40–70+ years—outlasting two or three standard asphalt shingle systems.
Their incredible durability is due to:
So while metal roofs are more expensive upfront, they can easily outlast two or three shingle roofs—while saving you money on repairs, energy bills, and home insurance costs.
Metal roofing for a house in Illinois costs between $10 and $18 per square foot.
For an average 2,000 square foot home, the total cost will range from $20K to $36K, depending on your roof’s pitch, materials used, and local labor rates. Despite the higher upfront costs—as compared to asphalt shingles—metal roofs pay for themselves in saved costs over a 15–25 year period.
For a precise quote, contact a reputable Illinois roofing company.
An onsite-rolled standing seam metal roof typically pays for itself in 15–25 years.
While more expensive upfront, metal roofs outlast up to three standard asphalt shingle roofs, can shave up to 20% off your annual homeowners policy, and lower cooling bills by up to 25% during the summer months (by reflecting solar rays).
Yes, a metal roof can increase your home’s resale value.
Buyers are particularly attracted to metal roofs for their durability, low-maintenance requirements (metal roof repairs are uncommon—even over decades of use), performance in severe weather, and energy efficiency.
Expect to recoup 60% to 85% of the installation cost upon resale, and raise your appraisal value by 6% to 10%.

While the metallic tapping of rain on a tin roof conjures a certain romantic sentiment, most homeowners don’t want their houses sounding like an airplane hangar every time it rains.
While metal roofs can be louder if not properly installed, installing over an appropriate roof deck with adequate insulation alleviates noise concerns for most homeowners—another reason working with an experienced standing seam metal roofer is imperative when installing metal roofs.
No, metal roofs do not attract lightning.
Lightning seeks the easiest route to the ground—targeting tall, pointy, and isolated objects. It is the shape of these objects, rather than the material, that attracts the lightning. (For example, a metal rod is not at a higher risk of lightning strikes than a tall tree).
In fact, the conductivity of a metal roof makes it safer in a thunderstorm than asphalt shingles.
Standing seam metal roofs are ideal for installing solar panels. This is due mainly to their durability. Able to outlast the 25 to 30-year lifespan of a modern solar system, there is less risk of having to remove solar panels for repairs or roof replacements.
If you’ve got additional questions about metal roofing for your home, feel free to reach out.
Kingdom Home Exteriors is an Illinois roofing company serving residential homeowners in Illinois and Indiana with on-site rolled standing seam metal roofs built to last a lifetime.
Since day one, our crews have focused on delivering honest, dependable service with workmanship you can rely on—with every metal roof installed, siding panel we cut, and client conversation reflecting our core values of integrity, quality, and compassion.
We look forward to hearing from you and learning about your roofing needs. To take the first step, reach out now for a free onsite consultation and detailed quote!
Kingdom Home Exteriors operates on a simple belief: do the job right the first time. And since day one, our trusted Illinois roofing company has focused on delivering honest, dependable service with workmanship you can rely on—with every metal roof installed, siding panel we cut, and client conversation reflecting our core values of integrity, quality, and compassion. Reach out for your free quote today!
| Website By ZIMMERMAN | Privacy Policy